Butcher Box vs. Heartstone Farm
These customers made the switch from Butcher Box to Heartstone Farm
"I had tried Butcherbox and was disappointed with the product. Heartstone Farm seemed different, and I can say the meat is of great quality."
- Mary Malone, New Hampshire

"We've tried ButcherBox in the past, Heartstone meat is definitely more flavorful. It's also better packaged (no leaking as everything defrosts, which has been a constant issue with ButcherBox) and comes at a more competitive price."
- Miriam Fisher, New York

"I ordered from Heartstone hoping I could replace Butcher Box considering their meat comes from Australia and Heartstone is right here in THE USA. The meat is amazing, tender and tastes amazing."
-Patrick Scofield, Uniontown, Ohio

Compare Butcher Box and Heartstone Farm
![]() | ![]() | |
---|---|---|
Grassfed Beef Sourced From | Australia | ![]() USA |
Sourced Directly From Farmers | X | ✓ |
100% Grass Finished | ✓ | ✓ |
Price for 9-12 lbs box | $169 | $159 |
Free Ground Beef for 1 year | ✓ | ✓ |
Customer Reviews on Site | 0 | 10,500+(4.9 avg rating) |
Have to Buy A Subscription | YES | NO |
Better Business Bureau Complaints | 177 | 0 |